Help with Cash Flow for Exchange Traded Funds

Any non-Tax accounting topics go here.
#1
Posts:
91
Joined:
10-Oct-2014 11:24am
Location:
Mid Atlantic
I have a client with a small investment; have the usual unrealized gains, interest inc and fees. They also have $50K withdrawal for expenses. My cash flow balances with the above without the EFT trading.

My peer reviewer cautioned that with my AICPA audit of the client that I should show gross activity from EFT's - all the in's and out's. So my question is if I already have the $50K as "Proceeds for appropriated expenditures" in the Investing Section, do I still need to add a line for "Sales of investments" - it's double counting; and would not equal

My problem is that there isn't much EFT activity.

the purchases were minimal EFT trading of $1000
and Sales of investment was mostly the redemption of of the $50K (lets say $49.5K)

I cant find any research that shows this; research is mostly showing the normal in's & out's If anyone can help.
 

#2
Posts:
107
Joined:
14-May-2019 3:57pm
Location:
Idaho
I don't do audits, but on a few GAAP financials I've gotten comments from internal reviewers to show Line of Credit activity on a gross basis vs just the net change. For example, LOC draws of $8,000,000 and LOC paydowns of $9,000,000 instead of just showing the net change of $1,000,000. Seems rather useless to me to show the gross of all those draws/paydowns that happen during the year. Sounds like you may have a similar situation with investing.

Can you argue that the 50k investment and/or he EFT trading is immaterial?
Maybe you can suggest to the client to liquidate the account and simplify their financial disclosure requirements.
 


Return to General Accounting



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests